DavidPerlmutterMD · 2017-11-12 · David Perlmutter (host), Daniel Amen

Proven Strategies to Prevent Disease - with Dr. Daniel Amen | The Empowering Neurologist EP. 55

51 research-tied claims examined: 1 contradicted 7 overstated 6 context 30 supported 7 unverified

6

Needs context

0:07:00Daniel Amenneeds contextlow

Adult humans produce approximately 700 new hippocampal stem cells each day.

"And in one study I read, you actually make 700 new stem cells, hippocampal stem cells, every day." (said at 0:07:00)

The speaker is referencing a landmark 2013 study by Spalding and colleagues (Cell), which used carbon-14 dating from nuclear bomb testing to estimate that approximately 700 new neurons (not stem cells) are added in each hippocampus per day in adult humans, corresponding to an annual turnover rate of 1.75% within the renewing neuronal population. However, this estimate refers to newly generated neurons rather than stem cells, and the broader scientific community remains divided regarding the extent of adult human hippocampal neurogenesis, with subsequent postmortem studies (e.g., Sorrells et al., Nature 2018) finding that neurogenesis drops to undetectable or extremely rare levels in adulthood.

0:09:35Daniel Amenneeds contextmoderate

A study from Harvard found that 40% of 40-year-olds and 70% of 70-year-olds have erectile dysfunction.

"And I read one study from Harvard that said 40% of 40-year-olds have erectile dysfunction and 70% of 70-year-olds." (said at 0:09:35)

This commonly cited rule of thumb originates from the Massachusetts Male Aging Study (MMAS), a landmark population-based study conducted near Boston in men aged 40 to 70. The study found that total erectile dysfunction (combining minimal, moderate, and complete impotence) was present in approximately 40% of men at age 40 and approximately 70% of men at age 70 (overall combined prevalence of 52%). However, most cases in younger cohorts represent mild or minimal dysfunction; severe or complete erectile dysfunction occurred in only about 5% of 40-year-olds and 15% of 70-year-olds.

  • context: Impotence and its medical and psychosocial correlates: results of the Massachusetts Male A… (The Journal of urology 1994) · cited 5122x in the literature
    "The Massachusetts Male Aging Study was a community based, random sample observational survey of noninstitutionalized men 40 to 70 years old conducted from 1987 to 1989 in cities and towns near Boston, Massachusetts. Blood samples, physiological measures, socio-demographic variables, psychological indexes, and information on health status, medications, smoking and lifestyle were collected by trained interviewers in the subject's home. A self-administered sexual activity questionnaire was used to characterize erectile potency. The combined prevalence of minimal, moderate and complete impotence was 52%. The prevalence of complete impotence tripled from 5 to 15% between subject ages 40 and 70 years." (abstract, results, passage verified)
    pubmedfull study (doi)
0:32:48Daniel Amenneeds contextlow

Ninety-four percent of traumatic brain injuries affect the frontal lobes.

"so of traumatic brain injuries, 94% of them affect the frontal lobes" (said at 0:32:48)

The speaker claims that 94% of traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) affect the frontal lobes. This statistic originates from a systematic review evaluating the clinical utility of single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) in TBI (Raji et al., 2014). The systematic review found that across cross-sectional brain SPECT imaging studies of TBI patients, the frontal lobes were the most common region showing neuroimaging abnormalities (94% of cross-sectional studies reported frontal lobe abnormalities, and 77% reported temporal lobe abnormalities). However, stating that 94% of all traumatic brain injuries affect the frontal lobes misrepresents what the statistic actually measures. The 94% figure refers to the proportion of cross-sectional SPECT studies in a systematic review that identified frontal lobe perfusion abnormalities among evaluated TBI patients, not a epidemiological population measure that 94% of all clinical TBI incidents involve frontal lobe injury.

0:35:33Daniel Amenneeds contextmoderate

Undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery increases the risk of cognitive impairment and Alzheimer's disease.

"and for example, if you have coronary artery bypass surgery, that increases your risk of having cognitive impairment and Alzheimer's disease." (said at 0:35:33)

The claim that coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery increases the risk of cognitive impairment and Alzheimer's disease requires important qualification. Postoperative cognitive decline and short-term cognitive impairment are common following CABG surgery, with meta-analyses reporting acute cognitive impairment in roughly 35% to 43% of patients post-CABG. However, evidence on whether CABG independently increases the long-term risk of Alzheimer's disease compared to non-surgical cardiovascular disease remains mixed. While some population studies show an elevated hazard ratio for dementia and Alzheimer's disease in patients with a history of CABG, large national registry studies show no overall increase in all-cause dementia risk compared to matched controls, and controlled longitudinal studies suggest cognitive trajectories in these patients are primarily driven by underlying vascular disease and cardiovascular risk factors rather than the surgery itself.

0:39:16Daniel Amenneeds contextlow

A long-term longevity study found that conscientiousness was the primary personality predictor of longevity, while highly cheerful or unworried individuals died earlier from accidents or preventable illnesses.

"So you might know the longevity study, the one from Harvard where they look at people over 90 years, the number one predictor of longevity was not happiness or a lack of worry—"Don't worry, be happy" people died the earliest from accidents or preventable illnesses, so I always wanted to be one of those people, I'm not—that the number one predictor was conscientiousness." (said at 0:39:16)

The speaker accurately describes the core findings of a landmark multi-decade lifespan study, although the research referenced is the Terman Life Cycle Study (analyzed extensively by Howard S. Friedman and colleagues, often called The Longevity Project out of Stanford/UC Riverside), rather than the Harvard Study of Adult Development. In analyses following participants from childhood across seven to eight decades, childhood conscientiousness emerged as the strongest personality predictor of longevity, whereas cheerfulness and high optimism were unexpectedly associated with reduced longevity, partly due to increased engagement in health-risk behaviors and preventable mortality. Meta-analyses have further confirmed the positive relationship between conscientiousness and survival.

0:43:43David Perlmutter (host)needs contexthigh

Approximately 6.5 million American children have an ADHD diagnosis, with about two-thirds receiving medication.

"the statistic is that about 6.5 million American children carry a diagnosis of ADHD and about two-thirds of them are medicated, most of whom are medicated with stimulants and basically amphetamines." (said at 0:43:43)

The speaker's statement combines statistics from different survey cycles of the U.S. National Survey of Children's Health (NSCH). According to 2022 NSCH data published by CDC researchers, an estimated 6.5 million U.S. children aged 3–17 years currently have an ADHD diagnosis (10.5%). However, in that same 2022 survey, 53.6% (approximately half) of children with current ADHD were receiving medication. The "about two-thirds" figure corresponds to earlier NSCH data cycles, such as 2016 (where 62.0% were taking medication) and 2011 (where 69% were taking medication).

Unverified means no publication matching the claim was located; it does not prove the claim false. Spotted an error? See the corrections policy - disputes from the people quoted are prioritized.