HoldsUp

FoundMyFitness · 2023-09-19 · Martin Gibala

Dr. Martin Gibala: The Science of Vigorous Exercise — From VO2 Max to Time Efficiency of HIIT

87 research-tied claims examined: 2 contradicted 4 overstated 3 context 68 supported 10 unverified

4

Overstated

0:09:42Martin Gibalaoverstatedmoderate

Elite endurance athletes typically train with an 80/20 intensity distribution, consisting of approximately 80% low-to-moderate intensity training and 20% high-intensity training across 25 to 30 hours per week.

"if you're a serious or an elite or very high-level endurance athlete, you're engaged in 15-20 sessions of training per week, you're training 25-30 hours a week of training. And the best evidence gleaned—there's some scientific evidence, largely opinion from high-level coaches and athletes—is about an 80/20 split there is sort of the ideal mix or ratio to optimize endurance performance: so about 80% low- to moderate-intensity type training and 20% high-intensity training" (said at 0:09:42)

Observational research in elite endurance athletes supports the concept of a polarized training intensity distribution, often demonstrating that approximately 75–90% of training time is spent at low-to-moderate intensities and 10–20% at high intensities. However, claiming that elite endurance athletes typically perform 15 to 20 training sessions totaling 25 to 30 hours per week overstates the typical weekly training volume and frequency for most sports. Published studies show annual averages for elite cross-country skiers, biathletes, rowers, and Grand Tour cyclists typically range between 15 and 20 hours per week across 10 to 15 sessions.

1:20:15HOSToverstatedmoderate

During exercise, the human brain preferentially consumes lactate over glucose when both substrates are present.

"because during exercise the brain consumes it more than glucose. So it actually, you know, you have both of them there, it'll go for the lactate over the glucose." (said at 1:20:15)

During exercise or hyperlactataemia, the human brain increases its uptake and oxidation of circulating lactate in a concentration-dependent manner, sparing and reducing cerebral glucose utilization (a phenomenon researchers describe as preferential lactate oxidation). However, the claim that the brain consumes more lactate than glucose in absolute terms is overstated: even during heavy exercise or high arterial lactate concentrations (~8 mmol/L), lactate accounts for approximately 25% to 33% of total cerebral oxidative metabolism, and glucose remains the brain's predominant fuel source overall.

1:29:08Martin Gibalaoverstatedmoderate

Studies by Rønnestad and Lundby found that elite cyclists with baseline VO2 max values of 72–73 mL/kg/min who incorporated 30-second repeated sprints experienced greater improvements in 20-minute time-trial performance and VO2 max compared to effort-matched continuous 5-minute HIIT repeats.

"There's even some recent evidence—I think there's renewed interest in the potential for elite endurance athletes to incorporate sprinting in their training. And there's a series of studies that's that's come out—Rønnestad, Carsten Lundby's work showing that when truly world-class level cyclists (we throw these terms around, highly trained, elite; these are cyclists with starting VO2 max values 72, 73 mils per kilogram per minute), and they randomize them to do either traditional HIIT for five-minute repeats or effort-matched 30-second sprints, and they sort of effort-matched, so whichever group you're assigned to, you're working at the highest effort you could, and they were work-matched, and what they found was the group that incorporated the sprints had a further boost to their performance, 20-minute time trial performance, and they actually had a small but significant improvement in VO2 max." (said at 1:29:08)

Rønnestad, Lundby, and colleagues (2020) investigated 18 elite cyclists (baseline VO2 max 73 ± 4 mL/kg/min) randomized to 3 weeks of either short intervals (3 sets of 13 × 30-second work intervals with 15-second recovery) or effort-matched long intervals (4 × 5-minute work intervals). The short-interval group achieved a significantly greater improvement in 20-minute cycling time-trial power output (4.7 ± 4.4% vs -1.4 ± 2.2%, P < 0.01) and fractional utilization of VO2 max. However, contrary to the claim, there was no significant group difference in VO2 max changes in this elite cohort. An earlier 2015 study by Rønnestad et al. did find greater VO2 max improvements with short vs long intervals (8.7% vs 2.6%), but in well-trained rather than elite cyclists.

1:39:20Martin Gibalaoverstatedmoderate

After roughly 15 seconds of an all-out Wingate sprint test, muscle glycogen utilization largely shuts down due to extensive lactate accumulation and pH changes.

"So, you know, basically after about 15 seconds of a Wingate, you shut off glycogen utilization. You've just produced so much lactate and your pH changes so much." (said at 1:39:20)

During a 30-second all-out sprint (such as a Wingate test), the rate of muscle glycogenolysis and anaerobic glycolysis peaks during the first 5–15 seconds and declines markedly during the second half of the bout as intramuscular acidosis (drop in pH) and metabolic feedback inhibit key enzymes such as phosphofructokinase and glycogen phosphorylase. However, claiming that glycogen utilization completely 'shuts off' after 15 seconds is an overstatement; glycogenolysis is markedly attenuated and energy provision shifts proportionally toward phosphocreatine resynthesis and oxidative phosphorylation, but glycolytic flux does not cease entirely.

Unverified means no publication matching the claim was located; it does not prove the claim false. Spotted an error? See the corrections policy - disputes from the people quoted are prioritized.