HoldsUp

Arthur Brooks

Dr. Arthur Brooks is a researcher who focuses on happiness, purpose, and strategies for managing negative affect. His work addresses the impact of technology overuse on well-being and the emotional challenges associated with high achievement. His published research includes exploring public health approaches to negative news media consumption.

46 claims checked on air: 2 context 8 contradicted 11 overstated 17 supported 8 unverified

What they said on air - supported

0:18:24supportedhighHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

When people are instructed in an fMRI to think about nothing, their mind wanders and the default mode network becomes active.

"When when we put people into the fMRI and you say, "Think about nothing," you can't do it. You immediately your mind just starts wandering, and the default mode network of the brain becomes active" (said at 0:18:24)

Functional MRI (fMRI) studies consistently show that resting-state conditions—such as when participants are instructed to rest, fixate, or think about nothing without an external cognitive task—foster spontaneous, stimulus-independent thoughts (mind-wandering) and robustly recruit the default mode network (DMN). Foundational and contemporary neuroimaging studies demonstrate that mind-wandering episodes during rest and low-demand tasks reliably activate the DMN.

0:18:56supportedhighHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

100,000 people died of drug overdoses in the last year.

"We created analgesics that got that escalated in power to the point we're able literally to get rid of all of the pain, and 100,000 people died of drug overdoses last year as a result." (said at 0:18:56)

National vital statistics data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) confirm that annual drug overdose deaths in the United States surpassed 100,000 per year during the peak of the overdose crisis (2021–2023), largely driven by potent synthetic opioids such as illicit fentanyl, before beginning to decline in 2024.

0:19:27supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

In Dan Gilbert's boredom experiments, 25% of women and two-thirds of men chose to administer painful electric shocks to themselves rather than sit in an empty room for 15 minutes.

"Dan Gilbert's experiments at Harvard on boredom, he shows that when people have to sit in a room with nothing to do except the option of pushing a button on a key fob to self-administer a painful electric shock, that 25% of women choose to shock themselves rather than being bored, and two-thirds of the dudes shock themselves painfully rather than being bored for just 15 minutes." (said at 0:19:27)

In a 2014 study co-authored by Daniel Gilbert and Timothy Wilson published in Science (PMID: 24994650), researchers evaluated participants asked to spend 15 minutes alone in an unstimulating room with only their thoughts. Participants had the option to press a button to self-administer an electric shock that they had previously rated as unpleasant and indicated they would pay to avoid. During the 15-minute period, 67% (two-thirds, 12 of 18) of men and 25% (6 of 24) of women chose to self-administer at least one electric shock rather than sit without external stimulation.

0:19:59supportedhighHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

In the psychological experiment where participants could choose between sitting with their thoughts or receiving an electric shock, one subject shocked himself 190 times in 15 minutes.

"Yeah, in the experiment, one guy shocked himself 190 times in 15 minutes." (said at 0:19:59)

In a series of psychological experiments by Wilson et al. (2014), participants were asked to sit alone in a room for 6 to 15 minutes with only their thoughts, with an option to self-administer electric shocks. A significant portion of participants (particularly men) chose to shock themselves rather than remain alone with their thoughts, including one extreme outlier who self-administered 190 shocks during the 15-minute period.

0:47:35supportedlowHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Studies of identical twins separated at birth conducted at the University of Minnesota show that positive and negative affect profiles are between 40% and 80% genetically determined.

"Most of this stuff is between 40 and 80% genetic, and we know this from identical twins separated at birth. You know those identical twin studies they did at University of Minnesota for all those years." (said at 0:47:35)

The claim is supported by publications from the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart (MISTRA) conducted at the University of Minnesota. In studies assessing personality and affect using instruments like the Multidimensional Personality Questionnaire (which evaluates higher-order dimensions of Positive Emotionality and Negative Emotionality), Tellegen and colleagues found that estimated heritabilities across scales ranged from approximately 39% to 58%, with subsequent analyses of the stable, trait-like component of subjective well-being across time reaching up to ~80%. Under GRADE criteria, quantitative genetic and observational twin studies provide low certainty evidence.

0:51:45supportedlowHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

People with clinical depression have high activity in the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex, and increased serotonin in the synapse lowers activity in that region.

"So, people who have clinical depression, high activity in the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex. And when there's more serotonin in the synapse, you find that that what it does is it lowers the activity in the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex." (said at 0:51:45)

Functional neuroimaging and positron emission tomography (PET) studies in patients with major depressive disorder demonstrate elevated baseline metabolic activity in the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex (VLPFC) and orbitofrontal regions. Treatment with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), which increase synaptic serotonin availability, is associated with significant reductions in VLPFC glucose metabolism and neural activation among treatment responders.

0:59:42supportedhighHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Greek yogurt contains high amounts of the amino acid tryptophan.

"Greek yogurt has a lot of tryptophan in it and that will actually hold you." (said at 0:59:42)

Dairy products and milk proteins provide substantial amounts of the essential amino acid tryptophan. Analytical profiling of commercial yogurts demonstrates that Greek-style yogurt has the highest tryptophan content among tested yogurt types (up to ~122 mg per 100 g in cow Greek-type yogurt), reflecting its concentrated protein content from the straining process.

1:08:44supportedhighHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Language centers of the human brain are localized in the left hemisphere.

"the language centers in your brain are in the left hemisphere and I asked you a right hemisphere question." (said at 1:08:44)

Extensive neuroimaging and clinical lesion evidence confirms that core language centers and the primary language network (such as Broca's and Wernicke's areas) are localized predominantly in the left cerebral hemisphere in the vast majority of individuals (approximately 95% of right-handed and 70% of left-handed individuals). While the right hemisphere plays supporting roles in prosody, narrative comprehension, and pragmatic processing, primary language production and comprehension functions remain strongly left-lateralized.

1:14:45supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

The dorsal anterior cingulate cortex processes the affective distress associated with physical pain and social rejection.

"sensory pain where the nerve endings are indicating that there's a problem—ouch—immediately leads to the affective part where the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex of the limbic system says, "I hated that," right? So ouch and I hate it are the two parts of pain. Now, when you have mental pain, it's only the second part. So if somebody rejects you, if somebody says, "Your work is stupid. You're a hack," your dorsal anterior cingulate cortex is going to go into overdrive" (said at 1:14:45)

Neuroimaging literature supports the claim that the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) plays a central role in processing the affective/unpleasantness component of physical pain as well as the distress associated with social rejection and exclusion. Seminal fMRI work and subsequent meta-analyses of dozens of neuroimaging studies confirm significant activation in the dorsal and ventral ACC during social exclusion paradigms (such as Cyberball) and correlate this activation with subjective self-reported distress.

1:15:54supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Contemporary popular music is objectively less melodic than music from past eras.

"music is objectively less melodic than it's been in the past, which actually affects us neurophysiologically." (said at 1:15:54)

Large-scale computational analyses of popular music over several decades confirm that melodies have become measurably simpler and less complex over time. A 2024 analysis of US chart-topping melodies from 1950 to 2023 identified significant melodic 'revolutions' in 1975, 1996, and 2000 marked by sharp decreases in pitch and rhythmic complexity alongside increases in note density. Broader network analyses of Western music across genres similarly demonstrate historical trends toward reduced complexity in both melodic and harmonic structures.

1:17:04supportedhighHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Observing acts of service or charity induces a state known as moral elevation in humans.

"When you see somebody serving somebody else, when you will see beauty, when you allow somebody to serve you in just pure love and pure charity, it gives you what the psychologist Rhett Diessner calls moral elevation." (said at 1:17:04)

Extensive empirical psychological research confirms that witnessing or observing virtuous deeds, charity, and acts of service elicits an emotional and psychological state known as moral elevation. Rhett Diessner and colleagues have extensively published on the concept of 'Engagement with Moral Beauty' and its role in experiencing moral elevation when observing prosocial behaviors.

1:31:49supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Writing about one's feelings reduces emotional intensity by shifting neural processing from the limbic system to the prefrontal cortex.

"You know, people find when they write about their feelings that their feelings don't feel so intense. The reason is cuz you can't actually write with your limbic system; you have to write with your prefrontal cortex. You want to move the experience of your emotions to the executive centers of your brain." (said at 1:31:49)

Neuroimaging studies on affect labeling (putting feelings into words) and expressive writing show that linguistic encoding of emotional experiences engages prefrontal regions—particularly the right ventrolateral prefrontal cortex (RVLPFC)—which in turn exerts an inhibitory downregulatory effect on the amygdala and other limbic regions, reducing emotional reactivity.

2:07:00supportedhighHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Lifelong smokers have a 7 in 10 chance of dying from a smoking-related illness.

"lifelong smokers have a seven in 10 chance of dying of a smoking-related illness, and that's an unhappy way to go." (said at 2:07:00)

Contemporary large-scale prospective cohort studies and epidemiological syntheses confirm that approximately two-thirds (around 67% to 70%) of deaths in lifelong or continuing smokers are caused by smoking-attributable diseases. In mature smoking epidemics, continuing smokers experience roughly a threefold higher all-cause mortality rate compared to never-smokers, losing approximately 10 years of life expectancy.

2:08:27supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Lifelong learning and high neuroplasticity preserve synaptic connectivity and allow individuals to maintain cognitive functioning even in the presence of physical neurocognitive brain degradation.

"People who have a life of the mind and are highly neuroplastic, they're just happier and healthier. And by the way, even if they have a whole lot of degradation, neurocognitive degradation, physically, they do better. You know, if you're learning a lot, your brain can hollow out practically, and you're still going to have enough of the connections, synaptically, in your brain that you're going to be able to function for a much, much, much longer time." (said at 2:08:27)

The speaker describes the cognitive reserve hypothesis, which posits that intellectual engagement, lifelong learning, and neural adaptability allow individuals to maintain higher cognitive functioning and clinical performance despite underlying physical neuropathology (such as Alzheimer's disease pathology, Lewy bodies, or vascular brain damage). Postmortem clinicopathologic cohort studies confirm that higher participation in cognitively stimulating activities throughout adulthood significantly accounts for preserved cognitive performance relative to measurable brain pathology burden.

2:11:36supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Studies show that even when people know social media displays curated, non-accurate versions of lives, they still believe the depictions.

"there's a couple of papers that shows that even if we know it's a lie, we still believe the lie. And even if we're participating in the lie, nobody puts on social media, "My wife just yelled at me again. Brutal." Nobody puts that on. "My kid just flunked math for the fourth time." Nobody puts that on there. And so, you know you're curating a version of your life that's not an accurate version of your life, and you know that you're consuming a curated version of other people's lives as well, but you still believe it." (said at 2:11:36)

Research on social media psychology and media presentation supports the concept that cognitive awareness of curation or digital manipulation does not reliably counteract social comparison or negative psychological reactions. Systematic and scoping reviews investigating disclaimer labels, media disclosures, and awareness of digitally altered or idealized imagery demonstrate that while explicit warnings increase cognitive awareness of image manipulation, they largely fail to mitigate upward social comparisons or associated distress, with viewers continuing to evaluate themselves against curated depictions.

2:13:35supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

In the Harvard Study of Adult Development, the relationship types most strongly correlated with happiness and wellness in older age are strong marriage and close personal friendships.

"what they find is that the two kinds of relationships that are most correlated with happiness and wellness is marriage and and or friends. You don't have to be married, and not everybody's marriage works out, but isolation from other people that are not just your children." (said at 2:13:35)

Findings from the longitudinal Harvard Study of Adult Development support the claim that strong, secure intimate relationships (such as marriage) and close personal support networks (friends) are key predictors of late-life health, subjective well-being, and cognitive outcomes, whereas social isolation or low security of attachment to partners is detrimental. For instance, research examining couples within the cohort demonstrated that higher security of attachment to spouses was significantly linked to lower depression, fewer marital conflicts, and greater life satisfaction and emotional well-being over time (PMID 26413428). Furthermore, long-term tracking of the study's participants shows that non-kin emotional support networks and nurturing relational environments significantly contribute to socioemotional well-being across adulthood (PMID 39146058).

3:25:27supportedmoderateHow To Build Lasting Happiness | Dr. Arthur Brooks

Findings from the Harvard Study of Adult Development (Grant Study) show that individuals who age to be both healthy and happy are characterized by seven specific factors: healthy diet, regular exercise, absence of smoking, moderation in alcohol/substance use, lifelong learning, effective coping mechanisms for life's challenges, and strong loving relationships (marriage or close friendships).

"You've heard of the Harvard Study of Adult Development, the Grant Study. That's following the same cohort 85 years now, starting in the late '30s... it turns out that almost all of the people in that quadrant—there's a lot of people who are unhealthy, a lot of people who are unhappy, but the ones who are happy and well did seven things, okay? Seven things. Now, some of them were obvious: diet, exercise, smoking, and drinking... Then there's the three that are not the obvious ones. Number one is continuing to learn... Two more is your technique for dealing with life's problems... And last but not least is the biggie, which is love." (said at 3:25:27)

Findings from the Harvard Study of Adult Development (including the Grant Study cohort of college men and the Glueck Study cohort of inner-city youth followed prospectively for over 60 years) identified seven controllable midlife predictor variables measured before age 50 that predicted late-life "happy-well" outcomes versus "sad-sick" or premature mortality at ages 70–80. These seven factors are non-smoking, mature coping mechanisms (adaptive defenses), absence of alcohol abuse, healthy weight/BMI, marital stability/strong relationships, regular exercise, and higher education/learning.

Fact-checked episodes

Publications